Zum Hauptinhalt der Seite springen

Participation begins with responsibility, trust and inspiration

Interview with Mervete Bobaj, conducted by Dr Susann Pham (German Center for Integration and Migration Research, DeZIM)

Drei Frauen stehen eng beieinander, haben die Arme umeinander gelegt und lachen gemeinsam.
© Pexels I Antonius Ferret

In this interview, Mervete Bobaj, founder of Mpower e.V., discusses participatory approaches in non-formal education with girls and young women with refugee and migration backgrounds, and the conditions that need to be in place for participation to be more than a formal offer.

Participatory approaches are now widely regarded as a key prerequisite in youth and educational work for promoting self-determination and empowerment. In practice, however, there is often a gap between the aspiration to enable participation and its actual implementation. Opportunities remain unused even when the “doors are open”. Participation research describes this as the risk of participation remaining merely formal or symbolic.

Mpower e.V.’s many years of practical experience point to one possible explanation: young people cannot be expected to “participate” immediately, meaning to articulate and reflect on their own perspectives, without pedagogical, cultural and political input. Participation requires groundwork. This includes building trust, providing inspiration and ensuring that organisations and professionals take responsibility. Mervete Bobaj explains what this can look like in practice using the example of the Girls Residency, a one-week series of workshops on participatory filmmaking.

In your experience, your own concepts work better than programmes offered by external providers. How did these methods develop?
These concepts and methods did not emerge overnight. They have developed over many years in response to concrete needs, experiences and processes. We have repeatedly developed plans, discarded them and adapted them. Over time, this has resulted in a methodological framework that has worked very well for us. At the same time, it is not rigid, but continues to evolve.

How do you make sure that the content really reaches the participants?
We explicitly understand our work as a form of inclusion work. Especially when working with marginalised groups, meaning young people with experiences of forced displacement, migration or refugeehood, this first of all means translating content into clear, age-appropriate language.

It is equally important to develop a sense of where the young people are coming from. What educational backgrounds do they have? What crises have they experienced? And why have they previously had no access to certain forms of knowledge and education?

Our peer approach is crucial in this respect. Our mentors were once participants themselves and have had similar, in some cases the same, experiences. They build a bridge to the young people and play a major role in shaping the educational approach. There are many peer projects, but in our case participants receive actual training that they can later pass on themselves. Without this approach, I do not think we would succeed in communicating knowledge in a way that really resonates. The young people tell us this directly as well.

Before you begin working on the actual content, you place a strong emphasis on inspiration. What does that look like in practice?
We deliberately do not start with theory. On the first day, we focus on inspiration and provide impulses by watching short films made by women of colour that also reflect the realities of girls and young women. We select the films carefully, including experimental and fictional works, and the groups then develop their own film ideas from these examples.

This time, one group decided to make a horror film, a genre one might not immediately associate with empowerment work. How did that come about?
The interest is actually not that surprising. At almost every film camp, one group wants to make a horror film. Young people between the ages of twelve and fifteen in particular enjoy being scared.

To be honest, I always wanted to reject the idea (laughs), because it is important to me that the girls associate the place we are staying in with something positive and feel comfortable there. And in fact, when we watched the finished horror film on the final evening, which turned out really well and was genuinely scary, everyone felt differently about the house afterwards. Before that, doors and windows had been open everywhere and everyone had moved around freely at night. That changed noticeably that evening.

Even so, this time it was the group’s decision, and I deliberately chose not to prevent it. We, as the facilitators, then take responsibility for how to deal with the consequences. A few years ago, we even successfully submitted a film to a feminist horror film festival and attended the festival together. That also helped build trust.

Mervete Bobaj

Mervete Bobaj

Founder and Managing Director of Mpower e.V.

Mervete Bobaj is the founder of Mpower e.V., an organisation dedicated to promoting the participation and empowerment of girls and young women with refugee and migration backgrounds, including through participatory film workshops such as the Girls Residency.

Mpower e.V.

Participation as a shared process

These examples show that participation does not arise simply because young people are given opportunities to contribute. It depends on conditions that organisations and professionals need to create actively: trust that develops through relationships with workshop facilitators, mentors and professionals; thematic and aesthetic input, for example through carefully selected short films; and peer structures through which knowledge can be shared in ways that connect with participants’ everyday lives.

In this way, Mpower e.V.’s practice reflects theoretical models of participation that understand participation not as a one-off opportunity, but as a gradual process in which decision-making power increases over time. At the same time, the example of the horror film shows that meaningful participation can also mean giving up control and supporting decisions that professionals themselves might initially have preferred to avoid.

From an empowerment-oriented educational perspective, the aim is therefore less about “giving a voice” to girls and young women with refugee experiences and more about creating the conditions in which they can find and use their own voice.

Mpower e.V., with its sub-project “InterEmp: Strengthening through Intersectionality”, is part of the collaborative project InterEmp. Together with the German Centre for Integration and Migration Research (DeZIM) and DaMigra e.V., the project focuses on intersectional empowerment and powersharing for women and girls positioned as migrants, and develops practice-oriented approaches and recommendations for action.

Stay Informed!

Stay Informed!
Subscribe to our newsletter to receive regular updates on the latest news, events, and developments from the Meta Project.

Click here to subscribe to the newsletter.

Sponsors

The project “Meta-project Migration, Integration, and Participation in Education” is funded by the Federal Ministry of Education, Family, Seniors, Women, and Youth and the European Union through the European Social Fund Plus (ESF Plus) as part of the “Integration through Education” program.

Platform Privacy Policy